Skip to main content
Home

Main navigation

  • Centers & Programs
    • Centers
      • Center for Energy Studies
      • Center for Health and Biosciences
      • Center for the Middle East
      • Center for Public Finance
      • Center for the U.S. and Mexico
      • McNair Center
      Center for Energy Studies
      Providing new insights on the role of economics, policy and regulation in the performance and evolution of energy markets.
      More Details
      The globe at night, lights in populated areas illuminated
      Center for Health and Biosciences
      Advancing data-based policies that promote health and well-being in the U.S. and around the world.
      More Details
      Female healthcare worker lifts finger to press digital buttons featuring topical iconography
      Edward P. Djerejian Center for the Middle East
      Developing pragmatic policy approaches to the region’s enduring political, economic and societal concerns.
      More Details
      Topographic map of Middle East
      Center for Public Finance
      Delivering research and analysis on the effects of major U.S. fiscal policies.
      More Details
      Stack of coins with mathematical figure overlays
      Center for the U.S. and Mexico
      Strengthening the binational relationship by addressing major concerns on both sides of the border.
      More Details
      Textured flags of America and Mexico
      McNair Center for Entrepreneurship and Economic Growth
      Providing actionable policy analysis and recommendations that aim to expand the economy through private enterprise.
      More Details
      Professionals gather around a large table with laptops, printed documents and coffee cups for a business meeting
    • Programs
      • China Studies
      • Drug Policy
      • International Economics
      • Presidential Elections
      • Religion & Public Policy
      • Science & Technology Policy
      • Space Policy
      China Studies
      Analyzing the influence of the transnational circulation of people, technologies, commodities and ideas in China.
      Read More
      Person walks alongside large banner with Chinese characters
      Drug Policy
      Pursuing research and open debate to develop pragmatic drug policies based on common sense and driven by human rights interests.
      Read More
      Marijuana
      International Economics
      Studying timely issues in global economic policy as well as developmental policy in foreign countries.
      Read More
      International paper currencies stacked together, showing range of colors and styles
      Presidential Elections
      Offering nonpartisan analysis of elections to better understand the changing dynamics of presidential campaigns.
      Read More
      An assortment of campaign buttons from a variety of US elections and political pursuits are displayed in a collage
      Religion and Public Policy
      Exploring how religion and cultural factors interact with public policy issues.
      Read More
      A worn path stretches between rows of olive trees
      Science and Technology Policy
      Addressing a broad range of policy issues that affect scientists and their research.
      Read More
      A scientist picks up test tubes from a rack.
      Space Policy
      Focusing on U.S. space policy and the future of space travel.
      Read More
      The International Space Station (ISS) orbits the Earth at sunrise
  • Events
    China flag with binary code overlay texture
    China Studies
    Mon, Jan. 30, 2023 | 5:30 pm - 7:30 pm
    How China is Winning the Battle for Digital Sovereignty See Details
    The front of Baker Hall, from across the plaza, with fountain in foreground
    Center for the U.S. and Mexico
    Thu, Feb. 23, 2023 | 5 pm - 7:30 pm
    Immigration Reform and the Impact on Children: A Town Hall Discussion See Details
  • Experts
    • Biomedical Research
    • Child Health
    • China
    • Conflict Resolution in the Middle East
    • Domestic Health Policy
    • Drug Policy
    • Energy
    • Entrepreneurship and Economic Growth
    • Global Health
    • Health and Biosciences
    • Human Rights and Refugees
    • International Economics
    • Islam and Politics
    • Latin American Energy
    • Middle East
    • Political Economy of the Arab Gulf
    • Presidential Elections
    • Public Finance
    • Religion and Public Policy
    • Science and Technology
    • Space Policy
    • Texas Politics
    • U.S. and Iran
    • U.S. and Mexico
    • See All Experts
    • Experts in the News
  • Support
    • Join the Roundtable
      Join the Roundtable
      Learn more about the Baker Institute’s premier membership forum, which offers unique opportunities to engage with fellows and policy-minded peers.
      Read More
      RT
    • Join the Roundtable Young Professionals
      Join the RT Young Professionals
      If you're interested in major political and public policy issues, and want the opportunity to network with industry leaders and your peers, then our young professionals organization is for you.
      Read More
      RYP Baker
    • Major Gifts
      Major Gifts
      Major gifts provide the funds necessary for the Baker Institute to explore new areas of study and research, and expand current programs.
      Read More
      Wallace S. Wilson meeting with former British Prime Minister Tony Blair
    • Endowments
      Endowments
      Endowment gifts provide the Baker Institute with permanent resources that support research programs, fellows and scholars.
      Read More
      Pictured from left are William Martin, Katharine Neill Harris, Ambassador Edward Djerejian, Alfred C. Glassell, III, and Pam Lindberg
    • Planned Giving
      Planned Giving

      Plan a gift that will ensure lasting, meaningful support for policy programs important to you.

       

      Read More
      meeting
    • Corporate Support
      Corporate Support
      Corporations can become involved with the institute in a number of ways and see the benefit from the research conducted by our fellows and scholars.
      Read More
      Wide shot of the Doré Commons during a Shell Distinguished Lecture Series event featuring Wim Thomas
  • About
    • People
      People
      Learn more about the Baker Institute's leadership and get contact information for the administrative staff.
      Read More
      Secretary James A. Baker, III, stands with a portion of the Berlin Wall, outside of Baker Hall
    • Student Opportunities
      Student Opportunities
      Through the internships on campus and beyond, Rice students can explore careers in public policy, or simply become better informed about important issues of the day.
      Read More
      Amb. Edward P. Djerejian speaks with students outside Baker Hall
    • Annual Report
    • Blog
    • Contact
      Contact Us
      Complete a form for event, media or other inquiries, and get directions and parking information for the Baker Institute.
      Read More
      The front of Baker Hall, from across the plaza, with fountain in foreground
  • Contact
  • Research
    • Economics & Finance
      Economics & Finance
      Read More
    • Energy
      Latest Energy Research
      Summary on Latest Energy Research
      Read More
    • Foreign Policy
      Foreign Policy
      Read More
    • Domestic Policy
      Domestic Policy
      Read More
    • Health & Science
      Health & Science
      Read More
    • All Publications
  • Facebook
  • Youtube
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Economics & Finance
  • Energy
  • Foreign Policy
  • Domestic Policy
  • Health & Science
  • All Publications
Center for the U.S. and Mexico | Research Paper

The Quest for Elusive Reform: Undocumented Immigrants in a Polarized Nation

March 24, 2021 | Daniel J. Tichenor
A close-up of an immigration stamp.

Table of Contents

Author(s)

Daniel J. Tichenor
Knight Chair of Political Science, University of Oregon

Share this Publication

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Linkedin
  • Download PDF
  • Print This Publication

To access the full paper, download the PDF on the left-hand sidebar.

Introduction: Biden’s U.S. Citizenship Act and the Politics of Immigration Reform

Major immigration reform to address the status of an estimated 11 million undocumented people living in the country has long been one of most contentious—and seemingly unattainable—items on the U.S. public agenda. Nearly all significant policy innovations in U.S. politics face formidable structural veto-points, cross-cutting interest group pressures, and deep partisan divides. Yet comprehensive immigration reform has proven especially difficult to achieve over time, despite wide agreement that the existing immigration system is flawed and in need of a drastic overhaul. For decades, congressional efforts to enact broad policy changes for the nation’s undocumented population have followed a tortured path of false starts, prolonged negotiation, and frustrating stalemate. As a result of legislative inertia, immigration governance over the past quarter century has been driven by unilateral executive action, state and local regulation, and judicial oversight. At the grassroots level, congressional inaction on comprehensive reform has also fortified a durable caste system that marginalizes undocumented individuals and undermines basic democratic norms and principles.

Undaunted by the political quagmires presented by this issue, the Biden administration made immigration policy a top priority during its first 100 days. Three weeks before his inauguration, President-elect Joe Biden announced that immigration reform was an urgent matter on par with the coronavirus, economic recovery, racial justice, and climate change. On Biden’s first day in office, the new administration unveiled legislative plans for legalizing most of the country’s 11 million unauthorized residents and issued 17 executive actions, including measures to preserve and expand the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, to rescind harsh deportation rules, and to provide a pause on most deportations from the U.S. interior. By mid-February, President Biden’s allies in Congress introduced his ambitious reform bill, the U.S. Citizenship Act, the centerpiece of which is a pathway to citizenship for nearly all of the country’s undocumented population. These blueprints promised the most sweeping overhaul of the nation’s immigration policies in generations, calling for “big, bold, inclusive immigration reform” that “leaves no one behind,” including immigrants without legal status. As he vigorously championed expansive legalization plans, Biden told reporters that immigration is an “irrefutable source of our strength” and “essential to who we are as a nation.” Biden’s rhetoric and policy goals were a dramatic break from the form and substance of the Trump presidency, which regularly used nativist appeals to fire up his rightwing base and sought to deport millions of undocumented individuals. Biden’s early brand of immigration activism was also a striking departure from the Obama administration, which expanded deportations and other enforcement efforts during its first term and chose not to propose immigration reform legislation when Democrats controlled both the House and Senate in its first two years.

Eschewing the usual formula of pairing legalization with new enforcement measures, Biden’s U.S. Citizenship Act spotlights two pathways to citizenship for undocumented immigrants. The first path offers immediate green cards and a three-year track to citizenship for so-called “Dreamers” (those who arrived in the United States as children), undocumented farmworkers, and people with temporary protected status—those who cannot return home due to wars or natural disasters. The second path also allows virtually all other unauthorized immigrants in the country to apply for citizenship after eight years if they pay taxes and pass background checks. Other provisions in the bill include economic aid and other assistance to address the root causes of migration out of Central America, as well as increases in the number of annual visas issued in the employment-based, family-based, and diversity categories. The bill’s congressional sponsors, Senator Bob Menendez (D-NJ) and Representative Linda Sanchez (D-CA), explained that they were “going big on immigration reform” by advancing an “all-of-the- above strategy” for legalizing the vast majority of the country’s undocumented residents.

While Republican critics in Congress called Biden’s immigration plan a “nonstarter” and an unacceptable “blanket amnesty,” immigrant rights advocates and Democratic progressives praised the new president for “leaning in pretty hard on this topic and moving in sync with us and being so closely aligned.” At the same time, both the White House and congressional Democratic leaders have acknowledged that their razor-thin majorities in the House and Senate mean that reform will be all but impossible without at least some Republican buy-in and votes. Reformers have also coalesced around a targeted strategy of pursuing smaller immigration bills rather than a massive package, elevating specific measures that are popular and likely to win bipartisan support. In particular, they have focused on an April deadline for immigration bills that were passed last year—such as protections for undocumented “Dreamers” and a farmworker modernization reform—that could be brought to the floor without lengthy hearings.

As the Biden administration, Congress, interest groups, and rival activists gear up for a new round of immigration reform politics, it is useful to recall past efforts to adopt legislation addressing the marginal status of millions of undocumented immigrants in the United States. The last major overhaul of national immigration policy affecting unauthorized residents was a bipartisan law passed thirty-five years ago—the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (IRCA). Since then, comprehensive reform efforts were launched and failed in 2001, 2006, 2007, and 2013. Immigration policymaking in these decades was not stuck in neutral, however. During the 1990s and 2000s, a number of laws focusing on border control and interior enforcement were enacted, while visa reform and legalization proposals were blocked. Taken together, these past attempts at immigration reform capture the rival interests and values unleashed by unauthorized immigration that make the formation of majority coalitions in Congress a tall order. National policymakers are well aware of the enormous challenges faced by earlier immigration reformers. False starts, grueling negotiations, and unappealing compromises have been the overwhelming norm, at least during the past quarter century. Past reform campaigns have also encouraged pitched battles both within and between each major party. In addition to these recurrent patterns, past reform efforts also illuminate significant developments that have made policymaking more arduous over time, such as increased partisan polarization and the growth of movement activism on both sides of this issue. Unforeseen crises also have upended legislative plans. Many lessons from previous immigration reform battles remain powerful for assessing today’s political environment, providing a window into the possibilities and parameters of future policy innovation. The last comprehensive legislation addressing undocumented immigrants—IRCA in 1986—provides a helpful place to start.

© 2021 by Rice University’s Baker Institute for Public Policy
https://doi.org/10.25613/JDN8-TN64
  • Print This Publication
  • Share
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Email
    • Linkedin

Related Research

Mexico Flag
Center for the U.S. and Mexico | Report

Mexico Country Outlook 2023

Read More
Rio Grande
Center for the U.S. and Mexico | Report

Treaty and Non-Treaty Mechanisms for Resolving the Rio Grande River Water Debt Dilemma

Read More
Hand types on laptop keyboard, with icons and symbols extruded from the screen; future tech, AI concept
Center for the U.S. and Mexico | Journal

A Social Network Analysis of Mexico’s Dark Network Alliance Structure

Read More
  • Facebook
  • Youtube
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Donate Now
  • Media Inquiries
  • Membership
  • About the Institute
  • Rice.edu
Contact Us

6100 Main Street
Baker Hall MS-40, Suite 120
Houston, TX 77005

Email: bipp@rice.edu
Phone: 713-348-4683
Fax: 713-348-5993

Baker Institute Newsletter

The email newsletter of Rice University's Baker Institute for Public Policy provides a snapshot of institute news, research and upcoming events.

Sign Up

  • © Rice University's Baker Institute for Public Policy
  • Web Accessibility
  • Privacy Policy